Most of the headlines coming out of President Obama's speech at the Urban League last night are focused on what he said about sensible gun reform. While I support him in that, it was what he said next that touched me deeply. This is something I've wanted to hear the President address, but haven't heard him talk about before. He gets it!!!
So I’m going to continue to work with members of both parties, and with religious groups and with civic organizations, to arrive at a consensus around violence reduction -- not just of gun violence, but violence at every level, on every step, looking at everything we can do to reduce violence and keep our children safe -– from improving mental health services for troubled youth -- to instituting more effective community policing strategies. We should leave no stone unturned, and recognize that we have no greater mission as a country than keeping our young people safe.
And as we do so, as we convene these conversations, let’s be clear: Even as we debate government’s role, we have to understand that when a child opens fire on another child, there’s a hole in that child’s heart that government alone can't fill. It’s up to us, as parents and as neighbors and as teachers and as mentors, to make sure our young people don’t have that void inside them.
It’s up to us to spend more time with them, to pay more attention to them, to show them more love so that they learn to love themselves -- so that they learn to love one another, so that they grow up knowing what it is to walk a mile in somebody else’s shoes and to view the world through somebody else’s eyes. It’s up to us to provide the path toward a life worth living; toward a future that holds greater possibility than taking offense because somebody stepped on your sneakers.
That’s the difference that we can make in our children’s lives and in the lives of our communities. That’s the legacy we must leave for the next generation.
In addition, the President said that today he would sign an executive order creating the White House Initiative on Educational Excellence for African Americans. I haven't seen the details on that one yet, but
The Root got a preview from a senior administration official.
...the White House Initiative on Educational Excellence for African Americans will be a part of the Department of Education and will work with the president and Cabinet-level agencies "to identify evidence-based best practices to improve African-American students' achievement in school and college." It will also build a network of people, grassroots organizations and communities to share those practices.
In addition, the executive order creates a presidential commission on educational advancement for African-American students, with commission members advising the president and Education Secretary Arne Duncan on broad-stroke strategies meant to enhance educational opportunities for black Americans of all ages.
A separate interagency working group will engage Cabinet agencies and senior officials at the White House in building programs "aimed at advancing outcomes for African Americans in early-childhood education; elementary, secondary and postsecondary education; career and technical education; and adult education," the administration official said.
"From allowing states to opt out of key No Child Left Behind provisions, introducing Race to the Top and releasing the Civil Rights Data Collection Report on educational disparities, President Obama continues to demonstrate the will to improve equity in education and access to college," remarked Ivory A. Toldson, Ph.D., a Howard University professor who is also contributing education editor for The Root.
Now THAT'S what I'm talkin' about!!! Its how you take the line "children are our future" from a campaign slogan to reality.
If we heal the hole in a heart, we won't have to worry abot the gun violence
ReplyDeleteYou know, those words made me wince. It sounded as though he were blaming the Colorado shooter's parents for not doing a good-enough job! Yes, there are kids who need more support. But I can tell you that the most loving parents in the world can produce an adult with mental health problems, problems they are not legally allowed to take action over.
ReplyDeleteWe don't know enough about the Colorado shooter's situation (and probably never will) to know what factors went into that.
DeletePresident Obama's remarks were - as he said at the beginning of the quote - about working on violence reduction in all its forms. And there are MANY children out there with holes in their hearts for all kinds of reasons - some of them related to their parents and some not. But all of us have a responsibility to reach out to them. It really isn't about who is to blame.
Suburban Correspondent, How could you hear that so incorrectly?
DeleteWhen he was talking about kids with holes in their hearts, he was talking about child on child crime. He was specifically talking about the non-publicized murders that happen in our cities everyday. He was talking to that audience about a terrible phenomenon that many in that audience are painfully aware.
He was not talking about the Aurora killer's parents.
Smarty, This is about the "white privilege" post.. I was struck by your analysis because it echoed what I know and have not been able to express. From cultural experience, I can testify to the truth of your evaluation.
ReplyDeleteChris Matthews was mildly irritated by the President's words. He is an Obama supporter, but he did not seem to analyze this thing as deeply as you did.
He had that knee-jerk reaction which could only occur if you believe that all things have been and are equal.
Did you hear that segment tonight? I appreciate Chris, but sometimes, like Sully, he breaks my heart.
I don't tend to watch the cable news shows so I missed Tweety tonight.
DeleteThe way I see it both Chris and Sully get some things right. But they both seem pretty tone deaf when it comes to their white privilege.
Yes. I agree.
DeleteI hope this initiative is better structured than "Race to the Top". I hope Arne Duncan isn't in charge of it. However I loved the President's words about giving children a broader view of the future than their own limited circumstances can provide (in whatever way they are limited). That is the true core of education and the dream of every teacher's heart.
ReplyDeleteI agree with the president that all of us need to show more love to children. However, his words that government somehow has the ability or duty to fill the hole in a child's heart was horrifying to me. Liberal or Conservative - do we really want to cede the responsibility of healing our child's heart to the government?
ReplyDeletePresident Obama truly believes that there is no problem that can't be solved by more government.
Nowhere in that speech does he say that it's solely the government's responsibility to heal each child.
Delete"Even as we debate government’s role, we have to understand that when a child opens fire on another child, there’s a hole in that child’s heart that government alone can't fill. It’s up to us, as parents and as neighbors and as teachers and as mentors, to make sure our young people don’t have that void inside them.
It’s up to us to spend more time with them, to pay more attention to them, to show them more love so that they learn to love themselves -- so that they learn to love one another, so that they grow up knowing what it is to walk a mile in somebody else’s shoes and to view the world through somebody else’s eyes. It’s up to us to provide the path toward a life worth living; toward a future that holds greater possibility than taking offense because somebody stepped on your sneakers."
I was not suggesting that he said it was solely the government's responsiblity - but that the government can fill some part of that child's heart. It could be interpreted that it is primarily the government responsiblity since "government alone can't fill" it.
DeleteIf you are a liberal - do you want a conservative government to fill a part of your child's heart? If you are a conservative, do you want a liberal government to fill a part of your child's heart?
If you need the government to fill some part of your child's heart - God help your children. Parents - yes. Relatives - yes. Neighbors - yes. Immediate community - yes.
Local government - NO. State government - No. Federal government - NO NO NO.
He explicitly did not say that the government can solve all problems. He always says that government cannot solve all problems, and always adds, " nor should it."
ReplyDeleteThe hole in the heart comment was specifically addressed to parents, teachers, mentors, neighbors. He was saying the exact opposite. I don't understand how you could hear that and read that and get it so totally wrong.
"...there’s a hole in that child’s heart that government alone can't fill. "
DeleteHow can you NOT think that he believes government has a role in filling your child's heart?
"...there's a hole in that child's heart that government alone cannot fill."
ReplyDeleteWhat does he suggest the government do? He speaks for leveling the playing field by providing the best possible avenues for education, affordable healthcare, maintaining the safety net so that people don't drop off into black holes of destitution and despair.
He is saying that government can play a role in helping people to improve their lives. In those specific areas he is saying that government can help to fill those holes. By once again offering opportunity.
My parents may love me a great deal, but I cannot go too far if I don't have an education, if I don't have a job, if I am ruined because I get sick. Government can help with these things, and it has helped many of my generation to move out of poverty and degradation.
That is what he meant.
So, the "hole in that child's heart" that lead them to do violence are holes in education, healthcare, and a safety net?
DeleteIf that's true, how does spending more time with them and showing them love (the president's words) create better opportunities in these areas?
Your own words decouple love from education. I'm confused....
"I'm confused..." I doubt it. But just in case, the confusion is in the structure of your own retorts. The President was not assigning causes for the metaphorical holes some children may have; he was describing both the limits of governmental reach and the specific things parents, mentors, teachers, etc. can do to nurture and protect children.
ReplyDeletePlaying word games to suggest there's some amphiboly in the POTUS' remarks which suggest parents' roles conflict in some way with BIG GUMMINT (cue scary music) is cheap and transparent.
"cheap and transparent"? Now you're just being hurtful. But thanks for introducing me to "amphiboly" (although I don't think you used it properly). I don't believe there is a fallacy resulting from faulty sentence structure as the president clearly indicated a role for government (with others - parents, etc) filling the holes in our children.
DeleteThe source of my confusion is the lack of addressing my specific questions - I responded to eveingeorgia's comments that contradicted her previous position and await her response.
Sorry I missed this discussion while it was "live."
DeleteBut I'd actually like to make the point that government CAN help heal the hole in a child's heart. How about teachers, or school counselors, or coaches, or foster parents, or probation officers, or child protection workers?
The nonprofit I run has about 25 people who every year help heal about 1,000 kids hearts in this community. Our funding to do that comes mostly in the form of grants from our local schools, city and county - some from medicaid.
All of that is government working with the private sector to help children.
So the President is right - government alone can't do it. But government DOES have a role to play.
Oops, I forgot to mention people like librarians, park and rec staff and yes, even police officers. Our police chief runs a mentoring program in the high school he graduated from.
Delete