Sunday, January 11, 2015

Lighthouse and Crossroads

In order to dispel any notion that by promoting unity/empathy/Ubuntu, the great leaders I mentioned previously are simply calling for the accommodation of our most profound beliefs/principles, I'd invite to to listen to or read President Obama's remarks at the 2009 Notre Dame Commencement.

For some context, when it was announced that the President would be the commencement speaker, anti-abortion activists on campus engaged in protests. But rather than dismissing them, President Obama went right to the heart of the matter and addressed the topic head on. It was a profound exhibition of strength, courage and empathy.


Here's how he concluded his speech.
And in this world of competing claims about what is right and what is true, have confidence in the values with which you’ve been raised and educated. Be unafraid to speak your mind when those values are at stake. Hold firm to your faith and allow it to guide you on your journey. In other words, stand as a lighthouse.

But remember, too, that you can be a crossroads. Remember, too, that the ultimate irony of faith is that it necessarily admits doubt. It’s the belief in things not seen...

And this doubt should not push us away from our faith. But it should humble us. It should temper our passions, cause us to be wary of too much self-righteousness. It should compel us to remain open and curious and eager to continue the spiritual and moral debate that began for so many of you within the walls of Notre Dame. And within our vast democracy, this doubt should remind us even as we cling to our faith to persuade through reason, through an appeal whenever we can to universal rather than parochial principles, and most of all through an abiding example of good works and charity and kindness and service that moves hearts and minds.

For if there is one law that we can be most certain of, it is the law that binds people of all faiths and no faith together. It’s no coincidence that it exists in Christianity and Judaism; in Islam and Hinduism; in Buddhism and humanism. It is, of course, the Golden Rule -- the call to treat one another as we wish to be treated. The call to love. The call to serve. To do what we can to make a difference in the lives of those with whom we share the same brief moment on this Earth...

I will not pretend that the challenges we face will be easy, or that the answers will come quickly, or that all our differences and divisions will fade happily away -- because life is not that simple. It never has been.

But as you leave here today, remember the lessons of Cardinal Bernardin, of Father Hesburgh, of movements for change both large and small. Remember that each of us, endowed with the dignity possessed by all children of God, has the grace to recognize ourselves in one another; to understand that we all seek the same love of family, the same fulfillment of a life well lived...

If nothing else, that knowledge should give us faith that through our collective labor, and God’s providence, and our willingness to shoulder each other’s burdens, America will continue on its precious journey towards that more perfect union.

The Heart of the Matter

When most people talk about globalization and income inequality, the talk about policies to alleviate the problem. That is an important part of the equation. But Pope Francis recently addressed the heart of the matter.
I recognize that globalization has helped many people to rise from poverty, but it has condemned many others to hunger. It's true that in absolute terms it grows world wealth, but it also increased the disparity and the new kinds of poverty.

What I notice is that this system is maintained with the culture of waste, of which I have already spoken several times. There is a politics, sociology, and also an attitude of rejection.

When at the center of the system there is not anymore man but money, when money becomes an idol, men and women are reduced and simply instruments of a social system and an economy characterized, indeed dominated by deep imbalances.
That reminded me of something David Simon said a few years ago when he talked about why he created the HBO series The Wire.
We are in the postindustrial age. We do not need as many of us as we once did. We don’t need us to generate capital, to secure wealth. We are in a transitive period where human beings have lost some of their value. Now, whether or not we can figure out a way to validate the humanity of the individual, I have great doubts...

The Wire is certainly an angry show. It’s about the idea that we are worth less. And that is an unreasonable thing to contemplate for all of us. It is unacceptable. And none of us wants to be part of a world that is going to do that to human beings. If we don’t exert on behalf of human dignity at the expense of profit and capitalism and greed, which are inevitabilities, and if we can’t modulate them in some way that is a framework for an intelligent society, we are doomed. It is going to happen sooner than we think. I don’t know what form it will take. But I know that every year America is going to be a more brutish and cynical and divided place.
And finally, I was reminded of what Derrick Jensen wrote in The Culture of Make Believe when he talked about the similarities between hate groups and corporations.
He said, "They're cousins."

I just listened.

"Nobody talks about this," he said, "but they're branches from the same tree, different forms of the same cultural imperative..."

"Which is?"

"To rob the world of its subjectivity."

"Wait - " I said.

"Or to put this another way," he continued, "to turn everyone and everything into objects."
Robbing the world of its subjectivity means removing empathy and our feelings of mutuality. It means creating distance between "us" and "them." It is also what Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. was addressing when he said this:
We are caught in an inescapable network of mutuality, tied in a single garment of destiny. Whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly.
When people accuse President Obama of being too accommodating with his opponents (liberals accuse him of being too accommodating with Republicans and conservatives accuse him of the same thing with global opponents), they fail to see that this is exactly the challenge he is attempting to address.

Here's how candidate Obama talked about it back in 2008 on Martin Luther King Day.
Unity is the great need of the hour - the great need of this hour. Not because it sounds pleasant or because it makes us feel good, but because it’s the only way we can overcome the essential deficit that exists in this country.

I’m not talking about a budget deficit. I’m not talking about a trade deficit. I’m not talking about a deficit of good ideas or new plans.

I’m talking about a moral deficit. I’m talking about an empathy deficit. I’m taking about an inability to recognize ourselves in one another; to understand that we are our brother’s keeper; we are our sister’s keeper; that, in the words of Dr. King, we are all tied together in a single garment of destiny...

We are told that those who differ from us on a few things are different from us on all things; that our problems are the fault of those who don’t think like us or look like us or come from where we do...

Every day, our politics fuels and exploits this kind of division across all races and regions; across gender and party. It is played out on television. It is sensationalized by the media...

So let us say that on this day of all days, each of us carries with us the task of changing our hearts and minds. The division, the stereotypes, the scapegoating, the ease with which we blame our plight on others - all of this distracts us from the common challenges we face - war and poverty; injustice and inequality. We can no longer afford to build ourselves up by tearing someone else down. We can no longer afford to traffic in lies or fear or hate. It is the poison that we must purge from our politics; the wall that we must tear down before the hour grows too late.

Because if Dr. King could love his jailor; if he could call on the faithful who once sat where you do to forgive those who set dogs and fire hoses upon them, then surely we can look past what divides us in our time, and bind up our wounds, and erase the empathy deficit that exists in our hearts.
Here's how he talked about it on a global scale during his acceptance speech for the Nobel Peace Prize.
Agreements among nations. Strong institutions. Support for human rights. Investments in development. All these are vital ingredients in bringing about the evolution that President Kennedy spoke about. And yet, I do not believe that we will have the will, the determination, the staying power, to complete this work without something more -- and that's the continued expansion of our moral imagination; an insistence that there's something irreducible that we all share.
The President reminded us of this when he memorialized Nelson Mandela.
Mandela understood the ties that bind the human spirit. There is a word in South Africa- Ubuntu – that describes his greatest gift: his recognition that we are all bound together in ways that can be invisible to the eye; that there is a oneness to humanity; that we achieve ourselves by sharing ourselves with others, and caring for those around us...He not only embodied Ubuntu; he taught millions to find that truth within themselves. It took a man like Madiba to free not just the prisoner, but the jailor as well; to show that you must trust others so that they may trust you; to teach that reconciliation is not a matter of ignoring a cruel past, but a means of confronting it with inclusion, generosity and truth. He changed laws, but also hearts.
There are those that say Ubuntu is impossibly naive and unrealistic. To them, I simply respond:
You may say I'm a dreamer
But I'm not the only one
I hope someday you'll join us (John Lennon, Pope Francis, David Simon, Derrick Jensen, Martin Luther King, Nelson Mandela, President Obama)
And the world will live as one.

Saturday, January 10, 2015

A Pragmatist's View of Change: Incentivizing Reform

Paul Glastris, Editor-in-Chief of the Washington Monthly, has written an important article in the current edition of the magazine. Here's the money quote:
But for the most part today’s left-leaning progressives are almost entirely focused on politics, economic justice, social issues, and the influence of money in politics. These are important subjects. But the vast complex of government is largely a black box to these folks. Other than defending the idea of government against anti-government conservatives, getting rid of the filibuster, reforming the primary system, and occasionally calling for more “accountability” and “transparency,” they would be hard pressed to articulate any coherent vision of how to reform the government we have, or any real understanding of how the damn thing works.

What I’m saying is this: there are energies being unleashed today that give the country a shot at reforming itself. But reform can’t and won’t happen until the left takes government—its structure and functioning—far more seriously, and until the right develops a stronger pro-government wing that can win over conservative supporters and compete with Democrats, challenging their blind spots while partnering on needed reforms.
This is exactly why I've been saying for years now that the best way to promote a liberal agenda is to demonstrate that government works. As Glastris suggests, the place to start is to understand "how the damn thing works." But the real challenge is to find a way to make large bureaucratic systems change. A systemic view tells us that there is always a natural tendency towards homeostasis. Systems fight change with every fiber of their being. So how does it happen?

Pondering that took me back to something Jim Stuart wrote almost a year ago about his observations on how Obamacare was impacting health care providers.
Healthcare providers are moving away from fee-for-service towards just emerging new service and payment forms that will reward quality, coordination of care, and new delivery methods that reduce system utilization. They are moving to EHR (electronic health records) aggressively, which will enable this productivity improving, cost-curve bending, system-wide change. In fact, I believe this highly complex system (medical care delivery) is beginning to self-organize around a new productivity improvement identity; that the cost curve bending is taking on a life of its own, and that the "half-life" of this system change will be long. This is the complete opposite of top-down, command-and-control org change. This is almost the only kind of big org change that works.
What he's talking about when he refers to "the only kind of big org change that works" is the process of providing incentives that make it in everyone's self interest to change. Rather than a top-down command-and-control process where the leader prescribes the changes that are necessary, a pragmatic leader identifies the outcomes that are desired and then incentivizes the system to change itself from the bottom up.

It should probably come as no surprise to us that our current Community Organizer-in-Chief has chosen methods of reform that incentivize change by appealing to people's self-interest.


Understanding that approach makes it clear how President Obama is attempting to reform our K-12 education system. Especially given the nature of local control when it comes to schools, any attempt to prescribe changes from the top would be ineffective. Instead, the President initiated something called Race to the Top, which laid out broad goals and incentivized schools to engage in the process of reform. For results, you can take a look at the Department of Education's most recent report on the program. I'll simply highlight these improvements:
At 80 percent, America’s high school graduation rate is the highest on record. Student test scores on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) are the highest since the test was first given 20 years ago. There have been double- digit gains on state tests at some of the lowest-performing schools – many of which had not seen any improvement for decades. And some of the largest gains have come in the places that have done the most to embrace reform, such as Tennessee and the District of Columbia.
Providing incentives isn't always a matter offering rewards. We all know that the reason Iran came to the negotiating table over nuclear weapons was because they were incentivized to do so by crippling global economic sanctions. And incentives don't always work - as we saw with the Veteran's Administration where the goals were unrealistic and effective oversight was not provided.

But to ensure a government that works via reform, it's important to develop a theory of how change happens in bureaucratic systems. A pragmatic approach to that is to keep a focus on the outcomes you are seeking and then incentivize people in those systems to work towards change in ways that meet their own self interests.

Friday, January 9, 2015

Sweet Baby James

This song feels like comfort at the end of today.


There's a song that they sing when they take to the highway,
a song that they sing when they take to the sea,
a song that they sing of their home in the sky, 
maybe you can believe it if it helps you to sleep,
but singing works just fine for me.

The Looming Clash Between President Obama and Progressive Democrats Over TPP

As Sahil Kapur notes, progressive Democrats in Congress want to flex their muscles in the lead-up to the 2016 election. The one place this is likely to explode the loudest is with the Trans Pacific Partnership trade agreement (TPP).

President Obama has already signaled that he is willing to work with the Republican Congress to get fast-track authority (an up-or-down vote in Congress) on the trade agreement.
The administration has argued that the trade deals will boost U.S. exports and lower tariffs for American goods in the fast-growing Asia-Pacific region, where the United States has faced increasing economic competition from China.

“Those who oppose these trade deals ironically are accepting a status quo that is more damaging to American workers,” Obama said at the Business Roundtable. “There are folks in my own party and in my own constituency that have legitimate complaints about some of the trend lines of inequality, but are barking up the wrong tree when it comes to opposing TPP, and I’m going to have to make that argument.”
For a brief rundown of what the TPP is all about, I found this article by Lydia DePillis to be extremely helpful. The main point of contention for progressives seems to be summed up pretty well by Nadia Prupis.
Democrats are rallying a coalition of labor, environmental, and religious groups, backed by a core group of lawmakers, to fight the implementation of the promotion authority they say would give the president free rein to arrange trade deals without input from Congress and with no regard for job loss, food safety, and financial regulation.
Both DePillis and Prupis point out that the specifics of what is included in TPP are mostly secret as the negotiations are still underway. And so the battle lines are not so much about what is in the agreement as much as it is about giving the President fast-track authority for approval.

I would simply say that I find it puzzling that these progressives seem to be suggesting that they trust a process controlled by a Republican Congress over their own party's leader - President Obama. Many of the people Prupis quotes are the same ones who earlier in his presidency were complaining that he didn't act more independently from Congress and have been applauding his recent executive actions.

It seems that a lot of this stems from the way progressives felt burned by the outcomes from NAFTA. As a result - there is a knee-jerk reaction against international trade deals.

For the record, the one trade deal negotiated previously by the Obama administration was with South Korea. That one had previously been in the works by the Bush administration. But President Obama pretty much renegotiated the whole thing and wound up getting the support of AUW because it opened up South Korea to American-made cars.

I understand the concerns progressives have articulated - especially about the secrecy. But no country is going to engage in negotiations like this without that protection. And the idea that we can trust this Congress more than President Obama to protect jobs, food safety and financial regulation is simply ludicrous.

Labor Force Participation and Criminal Records

As the economy continues to improve, Republicans are increasingly desperate to find ways to criticize President Obama's leadership. With more good news from the Department of Labor today (252,000 jobs created in December and unemployment down to 5.6%), here's the spin from Reince Priebus:
“We’re glad to see jobs created, but Republicans believe we can and must do better than this—especially when we see so many people leaving the workforce and earnings declining. We must do better than having millions of Americans without work—and millions more giving up on finding work altogether,” said Chairman Priebus.
Democrats would be more than happy to talk with Priebus about ways to increase earnings for the American people. But as I've pointed out before, the drop in labor force participation (LFPR) is the result of a lot of complex factors - including Baby Boomer retirements.

Recently Shane Ferro at Business Insider explored the possibility that criminal records might be having "a huge impact on labor force participation."
If the LFPR really is being depressed by companies that won't hire people with criminal records, that cuts a huge chunk of the population off from a lot of job options — they are more likely to get discouraged, and more likely to never return to the labor force if they are unemployed.

Just how many people does it affect?...

The most widely cited estimate is about 65 million people, a little over 20% of the population. That number comes from a National Employment Law Project report from 2011 on this problem. It used 2008 data from the Justice Department, which showed that there were 92.3 million people with criminal records in the 50 states...

How much does having a criminal record affect employment prospects? It outright blocks people from being hired for many government jobs.

In the private sector the question is blurrier. An outright ban on hiring people with criminal records is considered to be a violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, according to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission...But in practice, there are plenty of ways around that. Employers are allowed to consider a criminal record as part of a larger application.
Given the disparities in our criminal justice system, this affects primarily men of color (the current rate of unemployment for African Americans is 10.4%, compared to 4.8% for white people).

This is certainly an issue that deserves much more attention - especially as so many people are looking at the possibilities for criminal justice reform. You up for that Reince? Or are you simply content with blaming President Obama?

Wednesday, January 7, 2015

President Obama's Wage Initiative

It has become conventional wisdom among liberal politicians and pundits that Democrats running in 2016 should embrace a "new populism" centered on combating income inequality and middle class wage stagnation. There are likely some Democrats who need to be persuaded, but President Obama isn't one of them.

As I've written before, Barack Obama started talking about this issue before Elizabeth Warren ran for her current Senate seat. As a matter of fact, he regularly calls it "the defining issue of our time." Way back when he first announced his candidacy for president (more than six months before the Great Recession hit), he said that it was one of the reasons why he decided to run.

What we've heard less about from politicians and pundits are specifics of what can be done to combat income inequality. Basically most all Democrats support raising the minimum wage. But beyond that - what are the policies/proposals that can lead to change?

To answer that question, Danny Vinik interviewed Lawrence Mishel and Ross Eisenbrey, the president and vice president of the Economic Policy Institute (EPI) respectively, and uncovered what they call the "Obama wage initiative."
We believe that the Obama administration has pursued and is pursuing a series of initiatives that could be categorized as an Obama wage initiative, although the administration doesn’t package it as that, which is something that which we think is a mistake.
They go on to list five things President Obama has done as part of this initiative:
  1. DACA and his more recent immigration executive actions
  2. Executive order raising the minimum wage to $10.10 for federal contractors
  3. Fair pay and safe workplaces initiative
  4. Directing the Secretary of Labor to update the white-collar salary threshold for overtime pay
  5. Asked Congress for 300 more investigators for the wage and hour division
Given that the President told Steve Inskeep that he will now be focusing on long-term projects like "making sure that everybody is benefiting from this growth and not just some," I expect we'll be seeing more of this kind of thing in his forth quarter.

So here's a heads up to those promoting a "new populism:" identifying the problem with strong words and fancy graphs won't cut it. Its time to put your solutions on the table.

Immigrants and domestic migrants could be major factors in the Texas Senate race.

A few weeks ago I wrote about how MAGA influencers are trying to convince their base that - despite Trump's growing disapproval rates -...