Foot binding in China
Genital mutilation in Africa
Honor killings in the Middle East
Chastity belts in Europe
Scarlet letters and witch hunts in the U.S.
What do all of these things have in common? They are all examples of men's efforts to control when and with whom women have sex. Its been going on all over the globe for an awfully long time.
Some would have us believe that these things are rooted in religion. Its true that at times there has been a conflation of these activities with particular religions. But most of them pre-date any particular faith. So I think we need to dig a bit deeper to understand where they come from.
I remember years ago when I first learned about foot binding in China. I was an adult at the time and had never heard of this practice before. As I started to put that together with things like those other activities on the list up above, I realized that all over the globe this attempt to restrict when and with whom women had sex was going on without any coordination between cultures.
It all begs the question of what it is that the male in our species fears so much about women's sexuality that they would go to such lengths to try to control it. Now let me be clear, in asking that question, I had absolutely NO desire to denigrate the male half of our species. I love men. But I don't think we can ignore the fact that something seemed to happen around the globe at some point in our evolution that scared them and triggered this almost ubiquitous reaction. If we try to understand how that happened, we might be able to deal with the ways it continues to rear its ugly head today. After all, it is that need to control women's sexuality that plays out sometimes overtly and often covertly in the ongoing fight over abortion and our current mayhem about contraception.
About the time that I heard about foot binding in China I watched a discussion on TV about some fascinating research. Apparently men whose wives were currently pregnant were asked about their biggest fears. Number one on the list - as most would expect - was their concern about providing economically for the family. It was the number 2 item on the list that shocked me...is the baby really mine? As a woman - it had never occurred to me to think this would be such a common concern.
To go a bit further into something that is perhaps obvious, the only way for a man to have any assurance about who his children are is to control who his spouse has sex with. For women, that can never be an issue. But in cultures where a man's wealth and legacy are tied to his progeny, I can imagine that it becomes a HUGE concern.
I'm not saying that this is what currently drives all those who want to control women's sexuality today. I suspect that the fear has been passed down so powerfully for so long that even in our modern culture today it carries weight without much attention to its roots. But I believe that this is at least part of the source of some of our current battles about women's rights. To finally face that might be what's necessary to put it behind us.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Israel owes Obama a huge debt of gratitude
While we don't know the outcome of Iran's attack on Israel yet, it appears as though the worst has been avoided. According to report...
-
Back in 2011, David Roberts wrote that Republicans had become the "post-truth" party. [Republicans] talk about cutting the defici... -
When former President Obama nominated Judge Merrick Garland to a seat on the Supreme Court, a group called the Judicial Crisis Network (JCN)... -
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis's hand picked board overseeing the newly named Central Florida Tourism Oversight District (formerly the Re...
How do you know "most" of the efforts to control women's sexuality predate religion? I'd like to see some evidence for this. And in any case, the vastest component of misogyny and fear of women's sexuality comes from the major world religions, Islam and Christianity. Don't let them off the hook so easily.
ReplyDeleteI did acknowledge that there is often a conflation of the practices I listed and religion.
DeleteBut I know, for example, that honor killings pre-date Islam in much of the Middle East. And there is no connection between Islam or Christianity with genital mutilation and foot binding.
My point would be that this fear infected those Abrahamic religions. But if we want to understand the roots - we have to go back further.
It's not about women and sex. It's just about women. It's not about men's efforts to control when and with whom women have sex, it's about men's efforts to control WOMEN. You could very well title your piece, "Household Pets and Sex" for that is the way men see women, as things they OWN.
ReplyDeleteMy attempt here was not simply to name a problem but to try to understand where it comes from. Unless you think this desire to control/own women is genetically programmed, we need to ask that question.
DeleteControl women? I live with a wife and four daughters and have given up on having any control over this household. However, its been my family experiance where domantant mothers have taught their sons that its "unmanly" to allow women to have an equal say in their marriage. I had a cousin who fit this description. He would fly into a rage if he thought his wife had made a decision on her own. Living with him was like living with a coiled snake, you never knew when he was going to strike. I always thought it was fear of his mother finding out he couldn't control his wife that drove him into his rages. I knew him as a coward. On more then one occasion I confronted him over one thing or another and he wilted like deflated ballon. The fact was he could have beaten me to a pulp if he wanted to.
ReplyDeleteBottom line, I think all of these idiots are cowards who find themselves with someone they can lord over and control. These cowards explode when they think something is going to happen to let their buddies know they really are cowards.
Sorry for the confused post I only had a minute or two to type it
Herb S.