Saturday, January 12, 2013

Greenwald: The "war on terror" cannot end

A few weeks ago Jeh Johnson, the General Counsel at the Department of Defense, gave a speech at Oxford where he began the discussion about an end to the "war on al Qaeda."
"Now that efforts by the US military against al-Qaida are in their 12th year, we must also ask ourselves: How will this conflict end? . . . . 'War' must be regarded as a finite, extraordinary and unnatural state of affairs. We must not accept the current conflict, and all that it entails, as the 'new normal.' Peace must be regarded as the norm toward which the human race continually strives...

"There will come a tipping point at which so many of the leaders and operatives of al-Qaida and its affiliates have been killed or captured, and the group is no longer able to attempt or launch a strategic attack against the United States, that al-Qaida will be effectively destroyed."
Apparently this concept was a bit too much for Glenn Greenwald to comprehend.
Last month, outgoing pentagon general counsel Jeh Johnson gave a speech at the Oxford Union and said that the War on Terror must, at some point, come to an end...

But despite the happy talk from Johnson, it is not ending soon. By its very terms, it cannot.
The first thing to notice is that while Johnson referred to the "war on al Qaeda," Greenwald talks about the "war on terror." One can only assume that Greenwald prefers to use the framework of the Bush administration, since almost from day one of this administration the conflict has been refocused on al Qaeda.

But even more interesting is that Greenwald seems to be affirming that the actions he's spent so long criticizing (ie, detention, drones, etc) are indeed part of a "war." In that, he is agreeing with Attorney General Eric Holder. That pretty much negates every critique Greenwald has made of these policies given that he's based them all on domestic criminal laws - not the laws of warfare.

From there Greenwald's argument descends into gibberish. He basically says that because the current administration is engaging in these activities, they can't/won't stop...therefore the war is indefinite...therefore its wrong.

One has to wonder what happens to Greenwald's arguments when that "tipping point" that Johnson referred to is actually reached. He never addressed why the General Counsel at the Department of Defense would broach such a topic. Does he think Mr. Johnson just went rogue on the administration? Its much more likely that when that tipping point is reached, all of Greenwald's arguments will be shown to be false. And that's going to be pretty embarrassing for him. Therefore, the war cannot end.

Sorry...no Death Star


The White House  responded to a petition to build a Death Star.
The Administration shares your desire for job creation and a strong national defense, but a Death Star isn't on the horizon. Here are a few reasons:
  • The construction of the Death Star has been estimated to cost more than $850,000,000,000,000,000. We're working hard to reduce the deficit, not expand it.
  • The Administration does not support blowing up planets.
  • Why would we spend countless taxpayer dollars on a Death Star with a fundamental flaw that can be exploited by a one-man starship?...
We don't have a Death Star, but we do have floating robot assistants on the Space Station, a President who knows his way around a light saber and advanced (marshmallow) cannon, and the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, which is supporting research on building Luke's arm, floating droids, and quadruped walkers.

We are living in the future! Enjoy it. Or better yet, help build it by pursuing a career in a science, technology, engineering or math-related field. The President has held the first-ever White House science fairs and Astronomy Night on the South Lawn because he knows these domains are critical to our country's future, and to ensuring the United States continues leading the world in doing big things.

If you do pursue a career in a science, technology, engineering or math-related field, the Force will be with us! Remember, the Death Star's power to destroy a planet, or even a whole star system, is insignificant next to the power of the Force.

Friday, January 11, 2013

What makes a Cabinet position "important?"

In criticizing President Obama's record on Cabinet appointments, Jonathan Bernstein says this:
With John Kerry nominated for State, it also means all four of the most important cabinet positions will be male, at least as long as Eric Holder sticks around at Justice.
I assume the 4 he's referring to are the Secretaries of State, Defense, Justice and Treasury.

I know there is a lot of historical protocol assigned to Cabinet positions based on the order they were created. But does that mean that those that have been around longer are more important?

I hesitate to think about ranking these positions, but it sure does seem to me like the Secretary of Health and Human Services has and will play an enormously important role during this administration's implementation of Obamacare.

And I suppose that the Secretary of Energy is one of the more recent additions to the list - but in terms of issues we face today, could there be anything more important?

Its pretty typical of a patriarchal society to elevate things like foreign affairs and war above the "soft" issues of things like education and human services. So I'd propose to people like Bernstein that you take a minute to think about these kinds of assumptions before you go critiquing someone else's commitment to feminism.

Can you catch what's wrong with this graph?

A week ago I pointed out that Republicans like Sen. McConnell are hoping we'll forget that the work that's been done so far on reducing the federal deficit included more spending cuts than tax increases. That's why I was glad that the Center for American Progress did such a good job of pointing out that the 10 year projected deficit has been reduced by $2.4 trillion in the last 2 years.

But I wonder if you can catch what's wrong with this graph they used?

Photobucket

Last time I checked, three-quarters equaled 75% - not 62%. The only way you get to three-quarters is if you consider interest savings to be the same thing as spending cuts...which is ludicrous. The truth is that spending cuts have accounted for a little less than two-thrids of the deficit reduction.

That isn't nearly as egregious of a misrepresentation as the one Sen. McConnell was trying to pull off in the other direction - forgetting completely about the savings that have been captured so far. But we don't need overblown hyperbole to make a point.

Bless their hearts...the poutragers can't stop themselves from sinking to the level of the tea partiers

The poutragers on the left have gotten on a new bandwagon lately..."MINT THE COIN" as the alternative to the Republicans threatening to take the debt ceiling hostage. What is fascinating about their approach this time is that they are just outright acknowledging that they're embracing teh crazy in response to the crazy antics of the tea partiers.

For example, here's Paul Krugman's argument:
But wouldn’t the coin trick be undignified? Yes, it would — but better to look slightly silly than to let a financial and Constitutional crisis explode...

...it’s the president’s duty to do whatever it takes, no matter how offbeat or silly it may sound, to defuse this hostage situation. Mint that coin!
When it comes to doing silly undignified things, this kind of advice would have been met by our mothers with the traditional response of: "So if your friends jump off a cliff does that mean you need to follow them?"

Seriously, that's the grade school level of thinking on which this whole argument is based.

I understand that these folks are panicked at the threat of a default by the United States government. And isn't that just what hostage-taking is designed to produce...panic? Thank goodness we have a President in the White House who doesn't tend to go off the rails into childish responses at a moment like this - but has a habit of thinking through these things like an adult.

First and foremost President Obama has said that he will not negotiate with the Republicans about the debt ceiling. So what he's signaling from the outset is that he is not going to engage in this little game of chicken. We've already seen how that has resulted in Republican leaders backing off the threat.

But I've always suspected that the President wouldn't have made that strong stand without a plan to protect the American people from financial collapse if Republicans were stupid enough to go there. Of course he's not going to broadcast that plan and let the media tear it to shreds in the eyes of the public. And he's not going to sink to the level of the tea partiers in being silly or explosive.

That's why I think his plan will be something more in line with what Edward Kleinbard suggested.
He should threaten to issue scrip — “registered warrants” — to existing claims holders (other than those who own actual government debt) in lieu of money. Recipients of these I.O.U.’s could include federal employees, defense contractors, Medicare service providers, Social Security recipients and others.

The scrip would not violate the debt ceiling because it wouldn’t constitute a new borrowing of money backed by the credit of the United States. It would merely be a formal acknowledgment of a pre-existing monetary claim against the United States that the Treasury was not currently able to pay. The president could therefore establish a scrip program by executive order without piling a constitutional crisis on top of a fiscal one.

To avoid any confusion with actual Treasury debt, and to be consistent with the law governing claims against the United States more generally, the scrip would not pay interest in most cases. And unlike debt, it would have no fixed maturity date but rather would become redeemable in cash only when the secretary of the Treasury was able to certify that there’s enough money available in the Treasury’s general fund to cover it.

Finally, the scrip would be transferable, allowing financial institutions to buy it at a high percentage of its face value, knowing that the political crisis would almost certainly be resolved before long.
This idea also has precedent in that the state of California did it as recently as 2009.

I don't know if this is exactly what the President has in mind. And hopefully the Republicans will relent on this nonsense before we have to find out.

But I can assure you that meeting the tea partiers at their level of crazy is NOT something this President is likely to do.

Thursday, January 10, 2013

A demonstration of chauvinism

Just yesterday I was thinking about how hard it is to talk about our biases because so often they are invisible to us. When someone tries to point them out - we can't see them and so we get defensive. How to over come that was the question I was struggling with.

And then along comes this exchange between Joe Scarborough and Mika Brzezinski (esp starting at 5:30).

I know Joe couldn't see what he was doing. But can any honest observer NOT see how he wouldn't allow Mika a moment for a dissenting opinion? Even when she managed to get a word or two out - he belittled and mocked her. Of course, in his world, anyone who disagrees with him is only doing so out of some misguided (ie, childish) loyalty to President Obama...not because Mika happens to see the situation from a different (ie, adult) perspective.

There was not one shred of curiosity about how - as a woman - she might see the situation differently than he does. Instead he did everything he could to shut her up and shame her.

I'll give Mika some credit, she tried to do what Jay Smooth suggests when it comes to calling out racism. Instead of calling Joe "a chauvinist," she said that how he was handling himself in that situation was chauvinistic. Notice how Joe keeps trying to bring it back to "How DARE you call me a chauvinist!" As long he can defend that territory, he assumes that he doesn't have to deal with his particular behavior in this incident.

In the end, Mika wasn't successful in helping Joe see what he was doing. But what I'm hoping is that people who watch this will recognize what's happening. The next time someone says you did something chauvinist or racist or homophobic, think about NOT responding the way Joe did.

Wednesday, January 9, 2013

GOP Outlaws

I usually try to avoid hyperbole when it comes to talking about how extreme the Republicans have gone these days. In part that's because I want to reserve the well of rage for the really serious stuff. My energy for doing so runs out if I chase after every stupid thing they say/do.

But Steve Benen noted something yesterday that I didn't see many other people catch. He commented on this report from The Hill.
House Republicans signaled Thursday they will not follow rules in President Obama's healthcare law that were designed to speed Medicare cuts through Congress.

The House is set to vote Thursday afternoon on rules for the 113th Congress. The rules package says the House won't comply with fast-track procedures for the Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAB) — a controversial cost-cutting board Republicans have long resisted.

The rules package signals that Republicans might not bring up Medicare cuts recommended by the IPAB — blocking part of a politically controversial law, and resisting Medicare spending cuts.
(link added by me)

Benen's commentary focuses on the hypocrisy of Republicans insisting on reducing spending for Medicare while they promise to not follow the law in Obamacare that cuts costs in Medicare. He's totally right to point that out. But of course most of us have gotten used to the idea of Republicans being hypocritical when it comes to fiscal issues.

The bigger issue to me is the idea of House Republicans writing rules that require them to break a law passed by Congress and signed by the President.  I have to wonder if a Congress has ever done that before.

Imagine the implications...a Congress that gets to decide which laws they abide by and which ones they reject. That's a MUCH bigger issue than hypocrisy - its a recipe for chaos.

What is behind this is a Republican Party that is refusing to live by the rules of representative democracy. If they don't like the law, their option is to pass a bill to change it. They've been unable to do that - and so they're just going rogue.

That's dangerous.

Immigrants and domestic migrants could be major factors in the Texas Senate race.

A few weeks ago I wrote about how MAGA influencers are trying to convince their base that - despite Trump's growing disapproval rates -...