Wednesday, January 19, 2022

How the Media Covers Republican Obstruction

Two of the Democrat's major initiatives are currently stalled in the Senate: the Build Back Better Act and voting rights. Republicans have made it clear that they not only oppose these two pieces of legislation, they refuse to negotiate with Democrats on the goals of addressing the economic challenges faced by Americans or protecting the right to vote. 

So how is the media handling this obstruction? A few headlines tell the story.

USAToday: "As voting rights push fizzles, Biden's failure to unite his own party looms again"

Axios: "Biden's Epic Failures"

Washington Post: "Biden is failing politically, and not just because of Republican obstruction"

The New Statesman: "Joe Biden’s failure on voting rights could cost the Democrats the White House"

Perhaps you get the point. Failure to pass these bills is being laid at Biden's feet, not at Republicans for failing to even negotiate a compromise.

Politico took things a step further, suggesting that Biden's favorite columnists are revolting against him. Who are the columnists they talked to? The list includes David Brooks, Tom Friedman, Chris Matthews, and Josh Barro. Other than the fact that they are all white guys (mostly former Republicans), the one thing those four men have in common is that they're all suggesting that - even on voting rights - Biden has moved too far to the left. 

For example, Brooks said that "Biden's aggressive rhetoric on voting rights...represents how he has strayed from his roots as a moderate." Even if you buy into the way right wingers have politicized an issue like voting rights, Brooks is completely ignoring the fact that the Freedom to Vote Act was a compromise designed in part by Senator Joe Manchin - a so-called "moderate" Democrat.

Josh Barro also seems to suffer from having a bad memory when he told Politico that “The top issue for voters is the economy. So every day that you’re talking about voting rights legislation, you do not appear to be focused on the economic problem that’s the number one issue for voters.” He doesn't seem to remember that Republicans also obstructed the Build Back Better Act, which would have gone a long way towards addressing the economic problems faced by Americans. 

I won't hold my breath for a time when Barro calls out Republicans for their failure to even put forward an agenda to address "the number one issue for voters." Where are Republicans focused these days? On voter suppression. For example, on the first day Republicans regained control of the Virginia State Assembly, they immediately got to work on their number one priority.
This General Assembly session, various Republican Delegates and State Senators have proposed 20 bills to restrict or limit absentee voting...

Proposed bills include reinstating a requirement of an “excuse” to vote absentee, limiting absentee voting to a week or two weeks before Election Day and eliminating ballot drop-off boxes.

Other bills would require a photo ID to vote, require absentee ballots be mailed and received by Election Day to count, and eliminate the automatic absentee voter list – in which the registrar's office mails voters ballots for each election.
It's clear that Democratic Senators Manchin and Sinema are giving Republican obstructionists a boost by refusing to alter the Senate's filibuster rule to pass voting rights. But it's also important to remember that their votes wouldn't have been needed in 1982 when the Senate reauthorized the Voting Rights Act by a vote of 85-8 and it went on to be signed by President Reagan. Or how about 2006 when it was once again reauthorized, this time by a vote of 98-0, and signed by President George W. Bush?

When it comes to protecting the right to vote, where are the so-called "moderate" Republicans, like Senators Susan Collins, Lisa Murkowski, Mitt Romney, Bill Cassidy, and Richard Burr? They're all lined up with the obstructionists in their party. Are any of these columnists calling them out for moving too far to the right? Not a peep.

A group of former Democratic senators just put a lie to the idea that the push for voting rights is a move to the left. Doug Jones, who served as a senator from Alabama published a letter that was signed by a group that would fit the bill of being described as moderate. It included Senators Tom Daschle, Kent Conrad, Byron Dorgan, Heidi Heitkamp, Mary Landrieu, Blanche Lincoln, Mark Pryor, Mark Udall and Mark Begich. Here's what they said about voting rights.
Last year, we saw an unprecedented amount of misinformation regarding the winner of the 2020 presidential election, a violent attack on the U.S. Capitol in an effort to prevent Congress from certifying the election results, and partisan state legislatures trying to overturn the election in their states while erecting barriers to voting in future elections. Congressional Democrats have proposed multiple bills aimed at strengthening our democracy and advancing voter rights legislation that would instill confidence in our elections only to see them never reach the Senate floor. If the Senate cannot even begin to debate and vote on something as foundational as voting rights, we must reform Senate rules and restore the chamber to its rightful place as “the world’s greatest deliberative body.”

Protecting the freedom to vote should not be a partisan issue.

At this point, the only accurate way to tell this story is that, with an assist from Manchin and Sinema, Republicans have politicized an issue that was once bipartisan. They are not only obstructing efforts to protect the right to vote, they have prioritized voter suppression. The fact that the media isn't reporting it that way represents their own failure, not Biden's.  

3 comments:

  1. Obviously, the R party maintains its 'rights' to protect and represent only the white Americans. Otherwise, Mitch McConnell would not have uttered this: "After the vote, Republicans lined up on the Senate floor to shake Sinema’s hand, and Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) assured reporters that concerns about Black voting were misplaced because: “African American voters are voting in just as high a percentage as Americans.”

    ReplyDelete
  2. When the fascists in the GQP take over the country in November 22 and 24, the media, who have been going out of their way to help them with their fascist agenda, are going to be really surprised when they're put against the wall that's already wet with the blood of the Democrats who were executed before them.

    That's what these fascists ALWAYS do. Execute the opposition, then the media, then the intellectuals FIRST.

    You'd think these "Journalists" (Stenographers, really, since they don't report, just regurgitate whatever the Reich wingers tell them to.) would know the history of what happens to media reporters in totalitarian regimes a little better. Then again, since we don't actually HAVE a free and independent media in this country, given than all the major media is owned by 6 corporations who lean far to the right, we shouldn't be surprised.

    I'm going to miss democracy.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's just so frustrating to watch the NY Times and others contribute to the debacle. For another example, this week's podcast from Ezra Klein, interviewing ANOTHER Times OpEd columnist, Zeynep Tufekci, blames Biden for failure to act on Covid. She does mention that he has faced unusual opposition but rushes through the point, to the point of mumbling, as fast as humanly possible. She does not once mention even in that context the Court's rejection of mandatory vaccination (or, for that matter, Biden's early exceeding by far his goals for vaccination before the red states kicked up a fuss).

    What can she offer that he hasn't done apart from the one thing, vaccination, in which the US truly trails and the one thing that truly can make a dent in the spread of disease? She comes up with CO2 monitors in every conceivable indoor gathering place. Now, don't just imagine how many years that would take in a country of our size. Ask if the GOP Congress would approve or authorize funds for that. But she and Klein just don't care. Blame Biden.

    Oh, and Kevin Drum this week again celebrates his entry into the pundit class. On the subject of the key bills that a mere two senators have blocked, he blames the left for not going along with a done deal. Huh? All I see is a united party, left and center, apart from those two who won't even say what they might agree to because they know perfectly well they won't agree to anything.

    ReplyDelete

Disney's "Woke" Leader Returns, Which Doesn't Bode Well for DeSantis

Over the last couple of weeks, there have been some developments in the whole story about DeSantis vs Disney. First of all, Disney's boa...